Ratings and reviews
Steel City Sandwich Company Photos
Hours
Monday | Closed |
Tuesday | Closed |
Wednesday | 10:00 AM - 7:00 PM |
Thursday | 10:00 AM - 8:00 PM |
Friday | 10:00 AM - 8:00 PM |
Saturday | 11:00 AM - 8:00 PM |
Sunday | 12:00 PM - 7:00 PM |
Steel City Sandwich Company Reviews

I loved the pizza. Can't wait to try the rest of the menu. The pizza is fresh dough. The sauce is great! One of the best in Erie.

I got their cheese steak sandwich with all the fixings and a "small" order of fries. The sandwich is enormous and I was surprised that I didn't make a mess at all eating while on my road trip. The steak was nice and juicy and the toppings compliment to perfection. The bread has a light buttery toast to it and holds everything in, again, very well. It was seriously the best 12 I've ever spent in 2021. The service was fast and friendly and I will make sure to come back every time I'm in town! Note about the picture: I could only take picture of half the sandwich because the first half mysteriously disappeared suddenly after first bite! Have I mentioned the sandwich is amazing yet?

Order from here for every pizza night we have. Prices are great, the owner and their family/staff are always so friendly. Hands down best pizza in town. Wait is never longer than 20 minutes from time ordered. Prices can’t be beat either.

One of the best pizza pies in Erie. Erie has no competition for local pizza. But this is the best pizza

I was in Erie from out of town for a family wedding. needed something quick to eat. found Steel City Sandwich Company online and drove there to give them a try. Best steak sub I have had in years. not greasy at all and tasted great. The sub roll was amazing, and tasted like they baked it just to make my sub. service was excellent and very friendly. anytime I am in Erie, I will absolutely visit them again for another sub, and highly recommend them.

Great pizza with fresh dough with good sauce, and has some of the best subs in Erie. Ordered takeout so can't speak to service or location/atmosphere. Great eats

Hands down the best pizza you can get in Erie. Easily a 10/10.
Steel City Sandwich Company
Steel City Sandwich Company is a local favorite in Erie, Pennsylvania, offering an unforgettable sandwich experience. Whether you're in the mood for a hearty classic or something with a little more kick, this spot is a must-visit for anyone in the area. Located at 4801 Peach St, Erie, PA 16509, it brings a comforting, casual atmosphere with a diverse menu that will satisfy any craving.
If you’re looking for a restaurant that combines great flavors with a cozy, laid-back vibe, Steel City Sandwich Company ticks all the boxes. Known for its hearty sandwiches, this place has become a staple in the Erie food scene. They take pride in serving fresh ingredients, and every sandwich is crafted to perfection, ensuring an experience that keeps people coming back.
The menu here is a celebration of bold flavors and creative combinations. Whether you’re a fan of traditional deli sandwiches or something a bit more daring, there’s something for everyone. From juicy burgers to fresh subs and salads, you won’t leave hungry. What makes Steel City even more special is its commitment to offering locally sourced, high-quality ingredients that make their sandwiches stand out from the rest.
Their reviews speak for themselves, with visitors raving about the generous portions, friendly service, and the welcoming atmosphere that makes this place feel like a home away from home.
Steel City Sandwich Company’s menu is as diverse as it is delicious. You’ll find sandwiches packed with fresh meats, cheeses, and vegetables that cater to a variety of tastes. For fans of classic comfort food, the cheesesteaks are a must-try. For those looking for something a little more adventurous, there are unique creations like the BBQ chicken sandwich or the steak and onion hoagie.
The menu doesn’t just stop at sandwiches either—there are wraps, salads, and even a selection of sides like fries and onion rings to complement your meal. You can also wash it all down with one of their freshly brewed drinks, ensuring that every part of your meal is satisfying.
What sets Steel City apart is not just the variety but the quality. Each sandwich is made to order with fresh, locally sourced ingredients, ensuring every bite is packed with flavor. If you're someone who enjoys trying new combinations, you’ll love the seasonal specials that rotate on the menu. It’s clear that Steel City isn’t afraid to experiment, but they always do it in a way that complements their tried-and-true favorites.
If you're planning to visit, Steel City Sandwich Company is conveniently located at 4801 Peach St, Erie, PA 16509, a central spot that’s easy to find. It’s close enough to be accessible to both locals and tourists, making it a perfect stop whether you’re running errands or just in the mood for a great meal. The location is ideal for a casual lunch, a quick bite before a local event, or even a laid-back dinner with friends. The atmosphere is cozy yet lively, creating the perfect setting to enjoy a satisfying meal.
The location is also a bonus for those who want to explore Erie while satisfying their hunger. It’s situated in an area that offers plenty of nearby attractions, so you can grab a sandwich and then head out to visit some local shops or parks. For anyone unfamiliar with Erie, Steel City Sandwich Company is the perfect introduction to what this charming city has to offer.
The reviews of Steel City Sandwich Company consistently highlight their commitment to quality and customer service. Visitors frequently mention the friendly staff, quick service, and of course, the delicious food. Whether you’re a regular or a first-time visitor, you’ll feel like part of the Steel City family as soon as you walk in.
One of the most frequent compliments is the generosity of the portions. Customers appreciate that they don’t leave the restaurant still feeling hungry. Another common theme is the flavor—many people rave about how the sandwiches are packed with flavor in every bite.
Steel City also maintains a strong online presence, with plenty of positive reviews and social media shoutouts. The restaurant’s reputation is built on word of mouth, and it’s clear that this word is overwhelmingly positive. It’s easy to see why so many people make it a point to visit again and again.
In short, Steel City Sandwich Company in Erie, PA, is the perfect place to enjoy a hearty meal in a relaxed, welcoming setting. The combination of fresh ingredients, a diverse menu, and excellent customer service ensures that this spot remains a beloved choice for both locals and visitors alike. If you’re ever in the area, don’t miss out on experiencing this gem for yourself.
Have gotten take out numerous times and usually for pizza and subs. Got 2 grilled chicken salads that were excellent, but the steak and cheese Pittsburgh style was absolutely amazing!! The roll was soft and crisp (have gotten this as well numerous times and very consistent), added tomato and onions on the sub with hot sauce on the side! Just an absolute beast of a sandwich that doesn’t lack on flavor and quality! Also-BEST pizza in the city!!